By Nikita Vorontsovtested 28 Apr 2026updated 8 Oct 2026prices as of September 2026 (CharGen, Roll20, Foundry VTT and D&D Beyond re-checked 8 October 2026)
Short answer: Roll20 is the closest single-tool swap for online play, Foundry VTT is the one-time-purchase VTT, 5e.tools is the free rules reference, CharGen covers AI prep and art beside D&D Beyond, and Hero Forge makes the minis. D&D Beyond is the official 5e digital platform. For canonical rules, character sheets, and digital books, it is hard to fully replace. Update for July 2026: DDB now also ships its own VTT, Maps, in beta, free for every registered user. That narrows the gap with Roll20 and Foundry for basic online play, though it still lacks dynamic lighting and the automation depth of a dedicated VTT. For AI content, deeper VTT features, free SRD reference, and character art, the alternatives below still do the job better. Most working DMs run a mix rather than a clean swap. Here is how I use five of them.
The test: I ran each tool through the same dock-city campaign during March and April 2026. Sixteen NPC briefs, four player character sheets, three battlemap encounters, two settlement entries.
| CharGenRecommended | Roll20Winner | Foundry VTTRecommended | 5e.toolsRecommended | Hero ForgeNiche fit | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Free tier worth using | · | free to design | |||
| 5e rules reference | · | via SRD module | via 5e module | · | |
| Live character sheet for play | ·descriptive sheet or printable PDF, no live dice or HP (I rated this partial until October 2026) | · | · | ||
| VTT for online play | · | · | · | ||
| AI content generation | · | via 3rd-party modules | · | · | |
| Character portrait / mini visuals | · | asset library | · | ||
| Digital book / sourcebook access | · | via marketplace | via PF/5e modules | SRD only is openly licensed | · |
| Pricing model | Free + sub | Free + sub | One-time | Free | Per-mini |
| Entry paid tier | £8/mo billed annually, £9.99 monthly | $5.99/mo, $59.99/yr | $50 once | Free | $12.99/mini |
If you have been using D&D Beyond for character sheets and digital books, the honest path here is rarely a clean swap. Most DMs keep DDB for canonical rules and characters and add tools alongside. CharGen handles AI content generation. Roll20 or Foundry handles VTT play. 5e.tools handles free reference. Hero Forge handles physical minis. The full move away from DDB happens only if you decide subscription cost outweighs the rules integration. In that case, Foundry VTT plus 5e.tools plus CharGen covers most of what DDB delivers, with a steeper setup learning curve.

What I run alongside D&D Beyond, not instead. CharGen does the parts D&D Beyond was never built for: AI-generated NPCs, settlements, factions, regions, encounters, monster art, character portraits, VTT tokens, and 3D model files. Free tier covers casual prep. Honest framing here: CharGen is not a 5e rules engine. If you want canonical rules tooltips, integrated dice rolls against your character sheet, or digital book access, you stay on D&D Beyond. If you want the cast and content of your campaign generated and visualised, you add CharGen.
Roll20 is the most popular VTT and the closest thing to a full D&D Beyond alternative for digital play. Free tier covers most basic VTT use, integrated 5e character sheets, dice rolls tied to abilities, and a marketplace for adventures. The trade is that the rules content is not as deeply integrated as DDB's official tooltips, the UI feels older, and the in-built character sheet is fiddlier than DDB's. Worth noting since DDB shipped its own Maps VTT in 2026: Roll20 still has the deeper feature set (dynamic lighting, mature marketplace, established API scripting) that Maps has not caught up to yet. For DMs who want one tool for sheet plus VTT plus dice, Roll20 is the cleanest single-tool swap.
Foundry VTT is the best premium VTT I have used. One-time purchase (no subscription), self-hostable, and the 5e module ecosystem is genuinely deep. With the right modules installed, Foundry's 5e experience comes closer to DDB's integrated rules feel than Roll20 does. The trade is setup. You buy the software, install it, configure modules, and learn the system. The reward is a VTT that scales with serious play and avoids the per-month subscription fee.
5e.tools is the strongest free 5e reference on the web. SRD content fully indexed, cross-linked, with searchable spells, monsters, items, classes, and rules. Not a character sheet builder, not a VTT. Pure reference. For DMs who want fast canonical lookups during play without paying for D&D Beyond's digital books, this is the cleanest option. Some content is community-supplemented, so verify against official rules for tournament-legal play.
Hero Forge is the strongest character visual tool that pairs naturally with D&D Beyond. DDB's character sheet covers the stats. Hero Forge gives you the visual: a 3D mini you can pose, customise, and have printed and shipped in plastic, or export as a digital file to print yourself on a resin or filament printer. The trade is that Hero Forge does nothing for prep, NPCs, or campaign content. It is purely character visualisation. For player characters specifically, the combination of DDB plus Hero Forge plus CharGen for NPCs is one of the most common workflows I see.
| Tool | Free | Entry plan | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| CharGen | Yes, limited daily credits, no card required | £8/mo (Plus, billed annually; £9.99/mo monthly) | Plus, Elite, Ultimate tiers scale credits (900, 2,000 and 4,500 gold a month) and open all premium models; Ultimate adds batch operations. Annual billing is £95.99, £191.99 or £383.99 a year, shown as £8, £16 and £32 a month. UK pricing in GBP. |
| Roll20 | Real free tier | $5.99/mo (Plus) | Plus and Pro tiers add storage, dynamic lighting, and API scripts. Prices rose from $4.99/$9.99. Annual billing is $59.99 (Plus) or $109.99 (Pro) a year. |
| Foundry VTT | Trial via host's worlds | $50 one-time | One-time purchase, no subscription. Optional Forge VTT cloud hosting from $3.99/mo. |
| 5e.tools | Free, no signup | Free | Optional Patreon support. No paid tier. |
| Hero Forge | Free to design and pose | $12.99 per mini | Print-and-ship pricing scales with size and complexity across Standard, Premium, Color-Printed Plastic and Bronze. Hero Forge Pro subscription (from $3.99/mo) adds kitbashing, Token Maker, Scene Maker and HD portrait exports. A separate Pro+ Digital Download tier (from $14.99/mo) layers on top for 5 monthly digital credits towards STL/3D Digital mini downloads plus a free monthly featured pack. |
5e.tools for free SRD rules reference, Roll20's free tier for VTT play, and CharGen's free tier for AI content generation. None of these fully replace D&D Beyond's official rules integration and digital book access, but combined they cover most of what working DMs use DDB for. Foundry VTT requires a one-time purchase but pays back the cost over a long campaign by avoiding subscription fees.
Yes if you value canonical rules integration, digital book access, and the official Wizards of the Coast experience. D&D Beyond's character sheet with integrated rules tooltips and dice rolls is genuinely strong. The alternatives compete on different jobs: AI content (CharGen), VTT play (Roll20, Foundry), free reference (5e.tools), or character visuals (Hero Forge). Most DMs I know use DDB plus one or two alternatives.
Yes. The most common DDB-free stack is Foundry VTT with the 5e module for play, 5e.tools for reference, CharGen for AI content, and Hero Forge for character visuals. Setup is steeper than just opening DDB, but the long-term cost is lower and you avoid subscription lock-in. For one-shots or short campaigns, this stack may be more setup work than it is worth.
Roll20 has DDB sheet roll sync via the Beyond20 browser extension, a free third-party add-on that puts roll buttons on your DDB sheet and sends the rolls into Roll20, Foundry VTT or Discord (checked October 2026). Foundry VTT has DDB importers via 3rd-party modules. CharGen does not currently sync DDB sheets, but you can use a DDB sheet for rules play and a CharGen entity record for portrait, recap, and lore. Hero Forge sits alongside DDB without integration, you reference both.
It depends on whether the group plays online or in person. Online, Roll20's free tier is the lowest-friction start. In person, free 5e.tools for reference plus a CharGen free tier for content covers most casual prep, and you can add D&D Beyond if the group decides they want digital books and sheets later.
Each platform has its own terms. 5e.tools serves SRD content, and the SRD is the part that is safer for commercial use: SRD 5.1 is under both the Open Game License 1.0a and Creative Commons CC-BY-4.0, and SRD 5.2 (the 2024 rules) is under CC-BY-4.0 only, so current OGL state matters less than attribution (D&D Beyond SRD page, checked October 2026). 5e.tools also hosts material beyond the SRD, which is not openly licensed. Roll20 and Foundry VTT both support commercial content marketplaces under their own terms. CharGen's AI-generated content requires you to read current terms before publishing; commercial usage rights come with the Elite and Ultimate plans, and Free and Plus images are for personal use only (char-gen.com/pricing, October 2026). Hero Forge has separate terms for printed minis. Always check current terms before commercial use.
Yes, as of 2026 D&D Beyond ships Maps, its official virtual tabletop, in beta and free for every registered user. Maps includes quickplay maps, fog of war, tokens pulled from your DDB library, and dice rolls shared through the Game Log. The Master tier ($5.99/mo, or $54.99 a year) adds custom map uploads with 10GB of storage and homebrew monster support. It is deliberately simple (DDB's own team describes the design goal as 'Honda Accord, not F-16': Zac Cohn, D&D Beyond's DM tools product manager, in the 2026 development roadmap of 19 February 2026) and still lacks the dynamic lighting and automation depth of Roll20 or Foundry, so I have not swapped it in for either, but it closes some of the gap this page was written to address.
I ran each tool through the same dock-city campaign during March and April 2026. Sixteen NPC briefs, four player character sheets, three battlemap encounters, two settlement entries. D&D Beyond stayed in the loop as the rules reference. Pricing and feature facts re-verified against each platform's official site on 20 July 2026 (originally snapshotted 28 April 2026), then again on 18 September 2026: CharGen, D&D Beyond Maps (still beta, Master tier still $5.99/mo, dynamic lighting still absent), Roll20, and Foundry VTT pricing all came back unchanged. Hero Forge added a new Pro+ Digital Download subscription (from $14.99/mo, 5 STL/3D Digital credits monthly) since the July pass, split out from the base $3.99/mo Pro tier, updated above. On 1 October 2026 I re-checked CharGen's own prices against char-gen.com/pricing and its character sheet export against the live builder. On 8 October 2026 I re-checked Roll20's monthly and annual prices, Foundry VTT's $50 licence, D&D Beyond's Master tier ($5.99 a month or $54.99 a year) and Maps (still beta, free to host on a free account), and the SRD licence page.