By Nikita Vorontsovtested 28 Apr 2026updated 16 Oct 2026prices as of September 2026; CharGen prices re-checked 16 October 2026
My pick for linked prep is CharGen, which I make; for a free swap with no signup it is Kassoon. Donjon's free generators have been a DM staple for over a decade and they still work. Tables roll, results land, you keep moving. The trade is that everything is a flat list, disconnected from each other and from any linked visual content. Here are the six tools I tested as upgrades during March and April 2026. Update for July 2026: I corrected the Roll For Fantasy entry below, which originally described it as a name-generator library. That was a mix-up with a different tool (Fantasy Name Generators). Roll For Fantasy is actually a free visual map and dungeon-layout builder, which is a genuinely useful gap-filler when you want to place walls and props by hand, since Donjon's dungeon maps are rolled for you. Update for September 2026: I also corrected my own claim that Donjon has no visual output. It draws dungeon maps as images (with layout and image-size options), has a treasure map generator, and its Avatar Legends, Call of Cthulhu, Alien, and Blade Runner NPC generators include portraits. What it does not do is fantasy portrait art or linked, campaign-aware content, so the comparison below still holds, just on a fairer footing. Update for October 2026: I also corrected three of my claims about CharGen. Auto-linking happens when you generate one record from another, an NPC record has a portrait slot but no map, and batch tools are on Ultimate only.
The test: I ran each tool through the same dock-city campaign prep block during March and April 2026. Sixteen NPC briefs, four settlement entries, three shop inventories, eight names for recurring locations.
| CharGenWinner | KassoonRecommended | 5eMagic.ShopNiche fit | Roll For FantasyNiche fit | Leonardo AIWith caveats | NightCafeNiche fit | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Free, no signup | free tier, account required | account required | account required | |||
| NPC generator | · | · | · | · | ||
| Settlement / town generator | · | town creator, no linked NPCs | · | · | ||
| Shop / inventory generator | · | · | ||||
| Sane magic item pricing | ·balanced output, partial at best: no published method | DMG pricing | · | · | · | |
| Visual content (portraits, maps) | · | · | map + dungeon layout tool, no portraits | |||
| Linked entities (NPC -> settlement -> faction) | town only | · | · | · | · | |
| Save / export generated content | manual copy | manual copy free, Keeper tier saves and shares | map/dungeon tools save & print, rest is manual copy | |||
| Pricing model | Free + paid | Free + optional Patreon | Free + optional Patreon | Free | Free + paid | Free + paid |
If you have been using Donjon for NPCs and settlements, the switch to CharGen takes about ten minutes. Open the NPC Generator, drop in the role and one or two visual anchors, and CharGen drafts a stat block and a one-line motivation, with a portrait slot on the same page. The NPC saves to your workspace and links to whichever settlement or faction you tag it with. Your existing Donjon outputs still have value as quick fallback rolls when CharGen image credits run low (text generation never uses them). You do not need to abandon Donjon, you just stop reaching for it as the default.

What I use weekly, and I build it, so weigh my WINNER stamp with that in mind. CharGen replaces most of what I used Donjon for: NPCs, settlements, shops, loot tables, dungeons, names. The difference is context. A NightSerpent settlement in CharGen comes with notable NPCs and faction tensions in the record, a button that generates a linked NPC page for any of them, and a town map slot. A Donjon settlement is a paragraph. Free tier covers casual prep. The trade against Donjon is that CharGen needs an account and a free credit budget, while Donjon is open with no signup at all. The free tier has unlimited text generators, so the credit budget only bites on images.
Kassoon is the closest direct competitor to Donjon I have tested. Free, no signup, a similar table-driven approach, but with deeper town and settlement generators that link inhabitants, shops, and rumours together. NPC generation includes physical descriptions and personalities. Combat encounter builder accepts party level and difficulty. For a DM who wants Donjon's free-and-fast approach with one or two upgrades, Kassoon is the cleanest swap.
5eMagic.Shop solves one specific Donjon weakness: magic item pricing. Donjon's shop generator works but its pricing is the raw DMG numbers, which many DMs and I find inconsistent. 5eMagic.Shop applies the Sane Magic Item Prices methodology, which rebalances consumables and attunement items so the economy holds together over a long campaign. Free, no signup, narrow focus. If your shop output looks fine in Donjon, you do not need this. If pricing keeps tripping you up, it is the cleanest fix.
Roll For Fantasy is a free suite of 40 creator tools, and the standout pair is a click-to-build grid map creator and a dungeon layout tool where you place walls and props room by room, then save or print the result. Donjon's dungeon generator rolls a map for you; this lets you build the floor plan yourself, wall by wall and prop by prop. It also covers town, castle, shop-inventory, and loot generators, so it overlaps Donjon on breadth too. Interface is dated and there is no account or campaign linkage, but for hand-built maps and layouts rather than rolled ones, it is the free pick.
Donjon's visuals are maps and a few system-specific portraits, not fantasy portrait art. Leonardo fills that gap. When Donjon hands me an NPC paragraph, I drop the description into Leonardo for a portrait pass. Fantasy-tuned models (Phoenix, RPG v5) hold armour and lighting well. The catch is that pairing Donjon plus Leonardo means juggling two tools and two contexts, which is slower than running everything in CharGen. As a visual companion to Donjon's text, it works.
NightCafe is the friendliest landing for someone trying AI image generation for the first time. It pairs with Donjon the same way Leonardo does: Donjon gives you the text, NightCafe gives you the portrait. Output ceiling is lower than Leonardo or CharGen at top quality, and the free daily credit allowance stings on a longer prep block. For first-time AI users who want to extend Donjon with visual content without learning a complex tool, it is the lowest-friction entry.
| Tool | Free | Entry plan | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| CharGen | Yes, unlimited text generators, 10 gold a day for images (up to 100), account required | £8/mo (Plus, billed annually) | Plus, Elite, Ultimate tiers scale credits (900, 2,000 and 4,500 gold a month) and unlock premium models; batch operations are Ultimate only. UK pricing in GBP, annual-billing equivalent (month to month is £9.99, £19.99, £39.99). |
| Kassoon | Yes, no signup | Free (optional Patreon premium) | Optional Patreon premium tier: no ads, more saved characters, maps and notes, premium-only modules. Core generators stay free with no signup. |
| 5eMagic.Shop | Yes, no signup | Free | Optional Patreon Keeper tier: ad-free, plus saving and sharing shops and spellbooks. Core generators free. Shop-focused tool. |
| Roll For Fantasy | Yes, no signup | Free | No subscription tier found. Map and dungeon creator save/print, other generators are copy-paste. |
| Leonardo AI | 150 daily tokens (free tier) | $12/mo (Essential) | Essential, Premium, Ultimate tiers with 8,500, 25,000 and 60,000 monthly tokens (renamed from Apprentice/Artisan/Maestro, same prices). Token cost varies by model and resolution. |
| NightCafe | Earned daily via login/streak rewards, Daily Challenge, badges | $7.49/mo (AI Beginner, monthly billing; $5.99 annual-billed) | Cheapest paid AI image tier, with five plans up to AI Artist at $62.49/mo monthly-billed. Prices from NightCafe's help centre; the site's own pricing table is JS-rendered and did not load for my fetch. |
Kassoon is the closest direct free Donjon alternative. Same approach (random generation, no signup), with deeper town integration and an encounter builder. CharGen's free tier covers more ground but requires an account. For DMs who want Donjon's exact workflow with one upgrade, Kassoon is the swap.
Yes for quick fallback rolls. Donjon's name generators, dungeon layouts, and treasure tables are still solid and load instantly with no signup. In my experience, most working DMs I know use one of the alternatives as the primary workflow and reach for Donjon when they need a fast roll without opening another tool.
CharGen produces the most usable NPCs, with portrait and voice slots, stat hooks, and a link to the settlement they live in when you generate them from that settlement's page. Kassoon's NPCs are the strongest free text-only option, with physical descriptions and personality traits built in. Roll For Fantasy does not generate NPCs at all, its strength is visual maps and dungeon layouts. Leonardo and NightCafe handle the visual side but no NPC text.
5eMagic.Shop applies the Sane Magic Item Prices methodology, which many DMs and I find handles long-campaign economy better than the raw DMG numbers Donjon and Kassoon use. CharGen's shop output is balanced for your party level and game system but does not expose the pricing methodology directly. Leonardo and NightCafe do not produce shop content.
Yes. The most common pairing I see is CharGen plus 5eMagic.Shop (CharGen for the campaign layer, 5eMagic.Shop for sane magic item pricing), or Kassoon plus Leonardo (Kassoon for free text, Leonardo for portraits). Pairing always slows the workflow compared to one integrated tool, but free tools mix well.
Each platform has its own terms. Donjon, Kassoon, 5eMagic.Shop, and Roll For Fantasy generate from public-domain or original tables, generally safer for commercial use, but check each tool's terms. AI image tools (CharGen, Leonardo, NightCafe) require you to read the current terms before publishing. Model licensing changes regularly.
I ran each tool through the same dock-city campaign prep block during March and April 2026. Sixteen NPC briefs, four settlement entries, three shop inventories, eight names for recurring locations. Same prompt approach across the AI tools. Free-tier rolls only on the free generators (Donjon, Kassoon, 5eMagic.Shop, Roll For Fantasy) to keep the comparison fair. Original pricing snapshots taken from each platform's official site on 28 April 2026. Re-verified live on 22 July 2026: CharGen, Donjon, 5eMagic.Shop, and Roll For Fantasy fetched directly (the Roll For Fantasy write-up was corrected this pass, see below); Kassoon blocks automated fetching, so its listed facts are cross-checked against its own indexed generator pages via search rather than a direct site read; Leonardo AI's pricing page loads live but NightCafe's does not render its tier table for non-browser fetches, so NightCafe's paid-tier prices are flagged as last confirmed in April rather than guessed. Re-verified again on 21 September 2026: CharGen's live pricing page (free tier now lists unlimited text generators and 10 gold a day for images, paid tiers £8/£16/£32 billed annually, £9.99/£19.99/£39.99 monthly), Donjon's homepage and dungeon generator (which showed it does draw dungeon maps and includes portraits in several non-D&D NPC generators, so the earlier no-visuals claims were removed), Roll For Fantasy (40 tools, still free, no paid tier), 5eMagic.Shop (Patreon Keeper tier confirmed), Kassoon (premium tier confirmed via indexed pages, the site itself blocks direct fetches), Leonardo AI (token allowances from the live table, dollar prices via third-party trackers), and NightCafe (plan prices from its help centre, which lists monthly-billed figures and a new AI Creator tier). Re-checked on 16 October 2026: CharGen's live pricing page (unchanged prices, 10 gold a day up to 100 on the free tier, batch tools on Ultimate only) and CharGen's own product code for the linking, NPC art slot and settlement map claims, which I corrected.