By Nikita Vorontsovtested 28 Apr 2026updated 23 Sep 2026prices as of September 2026
Hero Forge is still the right call when you want a printed mini delivered to your door. For everything else, fast portraits, repeatable casts, free tier, sheet plus token plus voice plus 3D model files, there are better tools now. Here are the five I ran through the same prep block in March and April 2026.
The test: I ran each tool through the same dock-city campaign prep block during March and April 2026. Sixteen NPC briefs, four recurring-character recaps, eight token exports.
| CharGenWinner | Eldritch FoundryRecommended | Leonardo AIWith caveats | NightCafeNiche fit | ArtbreederNiche fit | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Free tier worth using | free to design, pay to print | 5 daily credits | limited credits | ||
| AI portrait generation | · | ||||
| 3D model output | model file export | design + printed mini | · | · | · |
| Print-and-ship pipeline | · | · | · | · | |
| Character sheet builder | · | · | · | · | |
| VTT token export | · | · | · | · | |
| Voice and music generation | · | · | · | · | |
| NPC, settlement, lore tools | · | · | · | · | |
| Multiple AI models in one UI | · | Leonardo's own models | · | ||
| Recurring NPC consistency tooling | save and reload poses | manual prompt save | · | trait pinning | |
| Entry paid tier (per month) | £8 | $10/mo (Unlimited) or $25/mini | $12 | $7.49 | $7.49 |
If you have been using Hero Forge for portrait references rather than printed minis, the switch to CharGen takes about ten minutes. Open the NPC Generator, drop in the role and two visual anchors you used in your Hero Forge pose (height, armour family, weapon type), and let it draft three takes. Promote your favourite, click into Token Maker for a VTT-ready crop, and the matching character sheet sits beside the portrait. Your existing Hero Forge poses still work as printed minis if you want both. Nothing here forces an either-or.


What I use weekly. CharGen produces a portrait, builds a usable character sheet from the same prompt, generates a VTT-ready token, and now exports 3D model files for self-print or third-party services. The whole loop ties back to a session note. Free tier covers most casual prep, with unlimited text generators and 10 gold a day for images (up to 100). If you want a finished mini delivered to your door, you still want a print-and-ship service like Hero Forge or Eldritch Foundry, but everything upstream of that lives in one workspace.
The closest thing to a direct Hero Forge competitor that I would send a player to. The part library leans heavier and more militant. Armour layers better. Weapons vary more. Resin print quality holds edge detail well in my test order. The interface is denser, which slows the first session and speeds up everything after that. Since my original test the pricing has shifted from a flat per-mini fee toward an Eldritch Unlimited subscription for unlimited STL downloads, alongside pay-as-you-go physical prints.
I keep Leonardo in rotation for ideation passes. When I want five very different takes on a single archetype before committing to a final portrait, it gives me that spread quickly. The fantasy-tuned models (Phoenix, RPG v5) hold armour and lighting well. The catch is that everything around the portrait, sheets, tokens, recap linkage, sits outside Leonardo. You will pair it with two or three other tools.
NightCafe is the friendliest landing for someone who has never used an AI image tool. Multiple model engines under one daily-credit budget, plus a built-in social feed that surfaces what other people prompted. Output is fine for casual character art. It loses to CharGen and Leonardo on raw quality at the top end, and there is no D&D-specific tooling around the image.
Artbreeder is the quirky one. Instead of typing a prompt, you blend traits from existing portraits to dial in a face. That is useful for matching a player's mental image of a recurring NPC. The result is more controllable than a prompt-only tool and visually narrower. Modern Mixer mode added more flexibility but it still does not compete on raw image quality with Leonardo or CharGen's premium models.
| Tool | Free | Entry plan | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| CharGen | Yes, unlimited text generators, 10 gold a day (up to 100), enough for 10 draft images, no card required | £8/mo (Plus, billed annually) | Plus, Elite, Ultimate tiers scale monthly gold and unlock batch and premium models. £9.99, £19.99, £39.99 billed monthly. UK pricing in GBP. |
| Eldritch Foundry | Free to design and pose | $25 per resin mini, or $10/mo for Eldritch Unlimited | Pay-per-print still works with no subscription required. Eldritch Unlimited (from $10/mo billed annually to $15/mo billed monthly, or $499 lifetime) now sits alongside it for unlimited STL downloads. |
| Leonardo AI | 150 daily tokens (free tier) | $12/mo (Essential) | Essential, Premium, Ultimate (renamed from Apprentice, Artisan, Maestro; same prices and token allowances). Token cost varies by model and resolution. |
| NightCafe | 5 daily credits | $7.49/mo (AI Beginner, billed monthly) | Five PRO tiers from AI Beginner to AI Artist, including the AI Creator tier at $39.99/mo. Quarterly billing saves 15%, annual usually 40%. Caps stack quickly on a busy week. |
| Artbreeder | Limited credits, no card | $7.49/mo (Starter) | Plans scale credit pool and download resolution. Starter and Champion tiers both dropped in price since April 2026. |
CharGen is the best free Hero Forge alternative for most DMs. The free tier covers casual prep, portraits arrive in under thirty seconds, and the same workspace generates character sheets and VTT tokens. If you specifically need a printable 3D mini, Eldritch Foundry is the closer like-for-like swap.
Only Eldritch Foundry prints and ships. Hero Forge and Eldritch Foundry both run their own print-and-ship pipelines. CharGen now exports 3D model files, so you can self-print or send the file to a third-party print service, but it does not handle the print and ship step itself. Leonardo, NightCafe, and Artbreeder are 2D portrait tools only.
Yes if you want a printed mini in your hand. Hero Forge's 3D builder, posing tools, and printing pipeline are still solid, and the free Basic tier still covers full-colour design. Pro ($3.99/mo billed annually, $5.99 monthly) now adds its own Token Maker, HD character portraits, and a Scene Maker, so for players already living in Hero Forge the portrait and token gap is smaller than it was. STL downloads now sit on a separate Pro+ Digital Download tier from $14.99/mo (five digital credits a month). The alternatives in this list mostly compete on different jobs (fast 2D portraits, character sheets, token exports). I keep Hero Forge in the toolkit for any character a player wants painted on their shelf.
CharGen, on balance. Free CharGen credits cover several portraits, a sheet, a token, and a session note. Leonardo's free tier (150 daily tokens) is generous for image-only work but does not include any campaign tooling. NightCafe's free 5 daily credits run out fast on bigger batches.
Only CharGen has a built-in token builder (Token Maker) that takes a portrait and outputs Roll20 or Foundry-ready crops. With the others you generate the portrait elsewhere then crop and frame in a separate tool, Photopea, Tokenstamp, or your VTT's import wizard.
Each platform has its own terms. Hero Forge and Eldritch Foundry's printed minis are typically fine for personal play. Commercial use varies. AI image tools (CharGen, Leonardo, NightCafe, Artbreeder) all require you to read the current terms, model licensing changes, and the answer in 2026 is not the answer it was in 2024. Check each tool's terms before publishing or selling.
I ran each tool through the same dock-city campaign prep block during March and April 2026. Sixteen NPC briefs, four recurring-character recaps, eight token exports. Same role-first prompt template across every AI tool. Same character concept fed into Hero Forge and Eldritch Foundry. Times measured wall-clock, not optimistic. Original pricing snapshots taken from each platform's official pricing page on 28 April 2026. Re-verified live on 24 July 2026: CharGen, Leonardo AI, Artbreeder, and Eldritch Foundry's pricing page (via a reader proxy after the site blocked a direct fetch) all loaded and were re-priced directly; Eldritch Foundry has since added an Eldritch Unlimited subscription alongside its pay-per-print option, and Leonardo AI renamed its paid tiers without changing prices. NightCafe's pricing page does not render its tier table for non-browser fetches, so its figures are cross-checked against third-party pricing trackers rather than a direct site read, and match the April snapshot exactly. Re-verified again on 23 September 2026: CharGen's free tier and plan prices were read from char-gen.com/pricing; Hero Forge's Basic, Pro, and Pro+ Digital Download tiers from its subscriptions page (via a reader proxy); Eldritch Unlimited from Eldritch Foundry's pricing page (unchanged at $15, $13, $10 per month by billing term, or $499 lifetime), with the $25 and $55 resin print prices confirmed via search; Artbreeder unchanged. NightCafe's help centre now publishes monthly-billed prices of $7.49 to $62.49 across five tiers, including an AI Creator tier this page had missed, so the NightCafe figures above were corrected. Leonardo AI's pricing page blocked every automated fetch this run, so its figures carry over from July unconfirmed.