By Nikita Vorontsovtested 3 Jul 2026updated 17 Oct 2026prices as of September 2026; CharGen prices re-checked 17 October 2026
Eigengrau's Generator (eigengrausgenerator.com) writes towns, NPCs, and quest hooks as prose paragraphs you can read straight to the table, free with no signup. The gap is visuals and linkage: nothing it generates comes with a portrait or a map, and every entity stands alone. Here are the five tools I tested against it in July 2026.
The test: I ran the same dock-city prep block through each tool in late June and early July 2026: one town, five NPCs, one quest hook, one shop.
| CharGenWinner | Eigengrau's GeneratorRecommended | DonjonNiche fit | KassoonNiche fit | WatabouWith caveats | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Free, no signup | free tier, account required | core generators free, optional Premium tier for ads/extras | |||
| Town / settlement generator | map layout only, no text | ||||
| NPC generator with personality | · | ||||
| Read-aloud prose output | structured, not prose-first | · | · | · | |
| Quest / plot hook generator | via entity hooks | rumour tables | rumour tables | · | |
| Visual content (portraits, maps) | · | · | · | maps only, no portraits | |
| Linked entities across generations | linked within one town only | · | town only | · | |
| Save / export generated content | in-session saves, no export | manual copy | manual copy | image export only | |
| Pricing model | Free + paid (GBP) | Free | Free | Free + optional Premium | Free |
If you have been leaning on Eigengrau's Generator for towns and NPCs and want content that carries a face and stays linked, the move takes one prep block. Run the NPC Generator in CharGen for the shopkeepers and locals from your last Eigengrau's town, set a role and a visual anchor, and CharGen returns a portrait and a personality hook. Tag it to a settlement and the link holds for the rest of the campaign. Eigengrau's Generator is still worth keeping open for the moments you want a fast, free paragraph with zero setup, particularly mid-session when a player wanders somewhere you had not prepped. Most DMs I have spoken to run both: Eigengrau's for the improvised beat, CharGen for the content they plan to keep.

What I built. CharGen covers the same ground as Eigengrau's Generator (NPCs, settlements, factions, quest-ready hooks) and adds two things it does not have: AI portraits alongside every entity, and links between them, so an NPC generated for a settlement stays tied to it. Eigengrau's read-aloud prose has a strong improvisational voice CharGen does not fully match, and it asks for nothing, no account, no credits. CharGen's free tier covers casual prep but runs on a daily credit budget for images (text generators are unlimited and free) rather than Eigengrau's unlimited rolls.
Eigengrau's Generator (also known as Eigengrau's Essential Establishment Generator) starts with a town and branches out. Click a building and it writes the establishment in full prose. Click an NPC inside it and you get a name, a description, and a personality, all worded to be read straight to the table rather than parsed from a table roll. Standalone generators cover mercenaries, magic items, traps, and taverns. It is free, open source under the MIT licence with 880-plus stars on GitHub, and needs no account. A built-in Saves feature lets you track and revisit what you have generated in a session. The trade against CharGen is that everything stays text: no portraits, no maps, and nothing links outside the single town you started from.
Donjon is the older, wider tool next to Eigengrau's Generator. Where Eigengrau's branches one town into its buildings and people, Donjon rolls dozens of separate generators (dungeons, towns, world maps, names, NPCs, treasure, encounters) across old-school AD&D, 5e, and sci-fi systems. Output is a flat table roll rather than Eigengrau's connected prose, and nothing links between generators. For raw generator breadth and system coverage, Donjon still wins. For a town that reads like a paragraph rather than a list, Eigengrau's Generator is the better voice.
Kassoon sits closest to Eigengrau's Generator in intent: both build a town and populate it. Kassoon's town generator links inhabitants, shops, and rumours, and its NPC generator adds physical descriptions and personalities. The output reads more like structured fields than Eigengrau's flowing prose, and there is no branching from an NPC into a deeper background the way Eigengrau's expandable entries work. A combat encounter builder scaled to party level is a generator Eigengrau's does not have at all. Kassoon now runs an optional Patreon-backed Premium tier (from £1/mo) that strips ads and unlocks premium modules, so it is no longer the pure donation-only site it was when this comparison first ran. Every core generator still works free with no signup.
Watabou's Medieval Fantasy City Generator and companion tools solve the one thing Eigengrau's Generator does not touch: a map. Feed Watabou a size and it draws a full city layout with districts and streets in its signature procedural line-art style, free and with no signup. It does not write a word of NPC or establishment text. The natural pairing is Eigengrau's Generator for the town's voice and Watabou for the shape of the streets, though that means keeping two tabs open rather than one integrated workflow.
| Tool | Free | Entry plan | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| CharGen | Yes, limited daily credits, account required | £8/mo (Plus, billed annually; £9.99/mo monthly) | Plus, Elite, Ultimate tiers scale credits (900, 2,000 and 4,500 gold a month), and only Ultimate can unlock batch generation (batch operations). UK pricing in GBP. |
| Eigengrau's Generator | Yes, unlimited, no signup | Free | No paid tier. Optional Patreon and Ko-fi support development. |
| Donjon | Yes, unlimited, no signup | Free | No paid tier at all. |
| Kassoon | Yes, unlimited, no signup | Free (Premium from £1/mo) | Optional Patreon-backed Premium tier removes ads and unlocks premium modules. Every core generator stays free. |
| Watabou | Yes, unlimited, no signup | Free | Optional Patreon support. No paid tier required for core generators. |
Kassoon is the closest free alternative for town-and-NPC generation, with shops and rumours linked to the settlement. Donjon covers more systems and generator types if breadth matters more than prose. For content with portraits and links across a full campaign, CharGen's free tier goes further than any of the text-only tools, though it requires an account.
Yes, especially mid-session. Eigengrau's Generator's prose is written to be read straight to the table with zero setup and no account, which makes it the fastest option when a player wanders off the map. Most DMs I have spoken to keep it open as a fallback even after adopting a tool like CharGen for planned prep.
Not directly. Eigengrau's Generator produces text only. Watabou's procedural city generator produces a free map you can pair with an Eigengrau's town, though the two do not link automatically. CharGen is the only tool in this comparison that generates a portrait alongside the NPC text in the same pass.
Eigengrau's Generator, Donjon, Kassoon, and Watabou all work with no signup and no account. CharGen requires a free account to save gold-based credits and generated content to a workspace.
Eigengrau's Generator has a built-in Saves feature that tracks and lets you revisit content within your session, but it is not built for export to other campaign tools. If you need generated NPCs and settlements to save to a workspace and export elsewhere, CharGen is the tool in this comparison built for that.
Yes. Eigengrau's Essential Establishment Generator is MIT licensed and hosted on GitHub with over 880 stars, built with Twine and SugarCube. Development is supported through optional Patreon and Ko-fi donations rather than a required subscription.
I ran the same dock-city prep block through each tool in late June and early July 2026: one town, five NPCs, one quest hook, one shop. Free-tier or free-access only across every tool to keep the comparison honest, since four of the five are entirely free with no required paid tier. Pricing and feature snapshots taken from each platform's official site and GitHub repository on 3 July 2026, re-verified against each platform's live site on 2 September 2026.